Archive for Thursday, February 23, 2006

Signs foreshadowed escape, worker says

February 23, 2006

A worker in the Safe Harbor Prison Dog program said she warned her boss, apparently to no avail, about getting too close to Lansing Correctional Facility inmate John Manard.

Safe Harbor Prison Dog program founder Toby Young, who is thought to have aided in John M. Manard's escape from Lansing Correctional Facility.

Safe Harbor Prison Dog program founder Toby Young, who is thought to have aided in John M. Manard's escape from Lansing Correctional Facility.

Prison escapee John M. Manard

Prison escapee John M. Manard

Jessica Kirby began working in the Safe Harbor program in September 2005; she had known the program's founder, Toby Young, for more than a year, though, through their shared passion as dog rescuers.

Kirby wasn't with Young at the prison the morning of Feb. 12 when, authorities say, Young drove the Safe Harbor van out of the prison gates with Manard, a dog handler in the program, hidden inside in a dog crate.

The news was surprising to Kirby, but she soon came to accept that Young was an accomplice in Manard's escape.

"I suspected," said Kirby, who is deaf and consented to an interview via e-mail this week. "They were really close, and I've told her over and over that he was manipulative. But she chose not to listen."

Young and Manard are now fugitives. Authorities say Manard's escape was well-planned and carried out with Young's help. The two are believed to have left with more than $10,000 cash, are armed with two semiautomatic pistols and may have changed their appearances with the aid of hair dye and an electric razor.


In retrospect, Kirby said there were any number of signs leading up to the escape that should have signaled something was amiss with Young, including:

¢ In the period leading up to the escape, Young was not keeping detailed notes about medical information on the dogs in the program. She was not bringing Kirby the distemper shots that were needed for the dogs.

¢ Young stopped taking Kirby to the prison for three weeks.

¢ Young expressed anger at the rescue community for criticism of the Safe Harbor program.

¢ On Feb. 11, the day prior to the escape, Young disappeared from the Safe Harbor adoption clinic, leaving just three people to handle the dogs and speak to potential adopters. Kirby, who is diabetic, said Young "was very late with our lunch and my blood sugar was getting low. I was torn between the dogs and my own medical need."

¢ The day of the prison break, Kirby went to a barn where dogs waiting to go into the program are kept and she found three short-haired dogs from the prison outside without water or protection from the wind. They had been left there by Young - and it was something Kirby never expected from such an animal lover.

Kirby said she had beaten herself up in the aftermath of the escape for not saying anything about Young's erratic behavior.

"I just worked and worked : yet did nothing," Kirby said. "I should have pulled her aside and told her to take sabbatical leave for a week or so. I should have told somebody at the prison that they were becoming too close. And I thought too little of myself to talk to the prison staff about my observations, for I thought they would laugh at me for they enjoyed the media attention of this program. I should have tried anyway. I'll live with that for rest of my life."

Kirby said she and Young had a "good working relationship. Not perfect, but close to it."


As for Manard, Kirby sees both the good and the bad.

She said Manard was the best dog handler among the inmates and that dogs were drawn to him. Kirby believed Manard was a dog whisperer.

"I don't claim to understand, but I know what I saw and studied," Kirby said.

She used as an example the story of a female lab/mix that "dragged me all over the place without stopping, nearly pulling my shoulder out of place. Then after a week with Manard, she walked beautifully on leash. I couldn't believe what I was seeing! One week! Usually it takes six months for average people" to train a dog on leash.

She said Manard, who was serving a life term for a 1996 carjacking and slaying, was a different person around the dogs.

"His face was stoic until he saw the dogs, and he came alive horsing around with them."

Kirby, who is well known throughout the tightly knit dog rescue community, said she puts a lot of trust in dogs being the best judges of character. And the dogs, she said, loved Manard.

Kirby related the story of a chow the program had taken in after it was thrown off a bridge and suffered a broken rib and elbow.

"Why would the chow trust people after going through that hell? And he followed John Manard everywhere, even with a broken elbow, which required surgery," Kirby recalled. "Dogs run away from monsters and they ran TO him. Why? I'll never understand now that I've read his history."

But there was Manard's other side, too. She said she, Young and Manard once got into a discussion over whether to crop the tails off some Doberman puppies. Kirby thought they should be left naturally; Manard took the opposite stance. They ended up toe-to-toe and Kirby said Manard's eyes came alive.

"The point of sharing this story is that I saw in his eyes how excited he was at the prospect of a mental fight," Kirby said. "He didn't care whether the puppies were cropped. He wanted some excitement in his life, and he got that by verbally arguing with other people."

Prior to the Safe Harbor program, Kirby said, prison had made Manard a dead man walking. He was in for life, his family stopped calling on him, he had nothing but a bleak future.

"There is no excuse at all for murder," Kirby said. "Even being on drugs, he still could choose not to kill. Yet, John Manard's family abandoned him. He is still a human - a murder yet a human all the same. They have their reasons. I'm not judging them. I'm just stating a fact that he was a dead man walking and that changed when he was accepted into Safe Harbor."


As for where Young and Manard are now, Kirby said her guess would be Mexico.

"It's too hard to get into Canada unless they have very good forged passports and birth certificates. Who knows? I'm from Canada - born and raised in Vancouver Canada, and I know it's harder to get in. Not impossible but harder. Mexico is a piece of cake."

As for what Manard and Young are doing, Kirby offers this assessment.

"They're dealing with stress. Bickering about where to go," Kirby said. "He is no longer at her mercy and reveling in his freedom yet knowing he's being hounded : And sex gets old fast. Even with a person you love and respect. So they're bickering : I'm sure of it."

Meanwhile, Kirby continues to work with Safe Harbor. She said she feels sorry for Young's husband and two children, who accepted Kirby as part of their family. And Kirby still has a deep attachment to Young.

"While I'm very angry at Toby for the choice she made, I still love her," Kirby said.

The anger stems from what will happen to Safe Harbor, the dogs in the program and the dogs that never might be saved because of her help in springing Manard from the prison.

"Her vision of the program was incredible," Kirby said of Young, "and it's biting the dust all over the country. Many people has been working on copying the program but : the recent event has caused a lot of damage. In the process, many deaths that could have been prevented have occurred."

Kirby, ever the animal lover, said she continues to receive e-mail pleas for the program to adopt animals, yet for now there's no way she's able to help. It's horrible, she said, knowing that dogs are put to death for no crimes except being born.


Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.